Home » Posts tagged 'ceasefire'

Tag Archives: ceasefire

Truth is falsehood — or is it the other way round?

The Guardian says:

The fate of the two-week ceasefire in the Iran conflict looked in peril on Wednesday as both sides gave divergent versions of what had been agreed, Israel intensified its bombing campaign in Lebanon and Iran halted the passage of oil tankers because of an alleged Israeli ceasefire breach.

So if the Guardian editor asked for a summing up of the situation, just to save space, it ought to be “There is no ceasefire. Zilch! It’s over.”

That would also be more truthful. The UN human rights chief, Volker Turk, talks of “pressure on a fragile peace” after calling Israel’s attack on Lebanon “carnage”! How fragile can you get? Peace is war — or war is peace — where have I heard that before? In truth (and let’s hang on desperately to that idea before it becomes “truth is falsehood” or “falsehood is truth”), in truth, I say, there never was a ceasefire, either here or in Gaza. The war will go on in both cases until Trump is triumphant. That’s what the MAGA doubters want. They don’t want “forever wars”, they want a quick undeniable victory that will Make  America Great Again. And Trump’s willingness to destroy “a whole civilisation” promises that “like never before”. Will he deliver it? Let’s hope not.

For peace – and against ceasefires

Am I missing something? I’m tired of the United Nations wringing its United hands about Aleppo and acting surprised because a ceasefire has failed, humanitarian aid hasn’t been delivered and the bombing has got worse. Of course it has. All the nations of the world are united in believing in war; all of them are armed to the teeth, the big and strutty ones with WMDs. War is the opposite of humanitarian. It’s the opposite of aid. War is destruction. War is murder. That’s what it’s for. Why would two (or in the Syrian situation, Gawd knows how many) antagonists at war be interested in aid to their victims? Or a ceasefire? (“Will it hold?” “Oh dear, there seem to have been violations.” What a surprise!).

This is why I can’t stand the mushy sentimentality surrounding the Christmas truce during the First World War. One English language textbook a few years ago used it in one of its lessons. The class weeps over a bilingual “Silent Night” in the trenches, sighs as it realises that the very next day both choirs went back to war, and then the class joins in singing some old wartime song popular with the British troops.

I don’t have an answer to all this. We don’t need ceasefires or humanitarian aid. We need to stop believing in war. Jeremy Corbyn doesn’t believe in war but, if he does get into government, I don’t know how he’ll try to persuade others. He’s set himself the task of trying to persuade his own party not to renew Trident (there’s a mountain to climb) and we can only join him in that effort and keep our fingers crossed. But it feels as if it could all be too late, especially since Iraq, and our creation of ISIS.

So, as I say, I’ve got no answer. I’m just tired of it, that’s all.